Old Homes

Quick answer: Yes, most of them. But a 100-year-old house gets a harder look from insurers, and what they look at hardest is what North Park homes tend to have: original wiring, old pipes, an aging roof, and a clay sewer line. If you’re buying, start the insurance search in the first days of escrow, before you remove contingencies. If you’re selling, knowing those weak spots early keeps a buyer’s insurance problem from becoming yours.
What makes an old house harder to insure?
Per the Consumer Financial Protection Bureau, what you pay depends on the cost to rebuild, the home’s age and roof type, local disaster risk, and the property’s claims history. On a 1915 Craftsman or a 1928 Spanish Revival, these are the usual flags:
Knob-and-tube wiring. In 2025, ABC7 reported Bay Area insurers declining or canceling policies on homes that still have it, even though the San Francisco Fire Department said it hadn’t seen a trend of fires tied to it. What this means for you: if an inspector finds active knob-and-tube, expect questions, and get an electrician’s bid early.
Outdated electrical panels. I’ve had clients struggle to get an affordable rate on homes with older panels. . If it’s an older one like a Zinsco, get an electrician’s bid and ask your broker how it changes the quote before you remove contingencies.
Galvanized plumbing. Old steel pipes rust from the inside. California’s residential insurance guide lists wear and tear and maintenance as generally not covered, so a pipe that simply gave out is often your bill, not a claim.
An older roof. Roof type is part of the price. Know the roof’s age before an insurer asks.
The sewer lateral. Per the City of San Diego, the property owner is responsible for maintaining the sewer lateral, including the part under the street. A sewer scope is cheap compared with a surprise.
Claims history. Insurers check a database called CLUE, which tracks claims for about seven years. If you’re buying, ask the seller for the home’s CLUE report.
The same details shape value, too: see How Do I Find Out What My North Park Home Is Worth?
What if a regular insurer says no?
There’s a backstop. The California FAIR Plan is for people who can’t get coverage from a regular insurer. Per the California Department of Insurance, it’s a limited fire policy, up to $3 million per location for residential property.
It doesn’t include water damage, liability, theft, or additional living expenses. For those you’d add a separate Difference in Conditions (DIC) policy. The Department’s advice is to shop the market first, then apply through a licensed agent or broker.
Per the Department of Insurance, as of August 2026, FAIR Plan growth slowed to 1.9% in the second quarter, and about 24,000 policies left the Plan in April and May.
What this means for you: options are improving, but an old house still needs a broker who shops widely.
What should I compare beyond the premium?
Coverage piece | What the state guide says | Why it matters on an old home |
|---|---|---|
Dwelling limit | Should be the cost to rebuild, not market value; land isn’t covered | Ask how the rebuild estimate accounts for plaster, wood windows, and other original details |
Replacement cost vs. actual cash value | Actual cash value deducts depreciation and generally won’t fully replace a destroyed home | On paper, a 100-year-old house has depreciated a lot |
Building code upgrade (ordinance or law) | Some policies don’t include it | Rebuilding a 1920s house means meeting today’s code |
Earthquake | Generally excluded; your insurer must offer it for an added premium | A separate decision, not part of the base policy |
Flood | Generally not covered | Ask whether your location calls for a flood policy |
Source: California Department of Insurance, Residential Property Insurance Guide.
One old-house bonus: the California Earthquake Authority offers a discount of up to 25% on its earthquake premium for wood-frame homes built before 1980 on raised foundations that have been properly retrofitted.
When should a buyer sort out insurance?
Early. Nobody wants to find out the oven is broken after the dough has risen. Settle insurance before you remove your investigation contingency, and remember your lender typically has to approve the policy.
Book the inspection and a sewer scope right away.
Get an electrician’s bid if there’s original wiring or an older panel.
Ask the seller for a CLUE report.
Get written quotes from a broker, with premium, deductible, limits, and exclusions.
Show the quote you’re choosing to your loan officer.
Already own? If your insurer won’t renew, California requires written notice at least 75 days before the policy expires, with the reason. Use that time to shop.
What does this mean around North Park?
Nearly every street I work has this housing stock. The Craftsmans in the Dryden Historic District and Burlingame, the Victorians in South Park and Golden Hill, the Spanish Revivals in Kensington and University Heights, and the bungalow courts in Normal Heights are mostly 90 to 130 years old. Some have updated wiring and plumbing. Some don’t, and you can’t tell from the porch.
Fire maps matter here too. The City of San Diego adopted an updated Fire Hazard Severity Zone map in 2025 (final passage July 31, 2025) that adds areas San Diego Fire-Rescue identified beyond the state’s designations. If a home backs onto one of the canyons around Kensington, Normal Heights, or Mission Hills, check it against the current map.
For sellers, this is a prep question. Knowing about the wiring, pipes, and sewer line before you list lets you decide what to fix and disclose, instead of hearing it in a repair request. It takes a specific agent to know these homes.
Want help sizing up an old house before escrow gets tight?
Text or call me at (619) 853-2393, or book a quick call. I’m not an insurance broker, and the coverage choice belongs with a licensed one. What I can do is help you learn early what a house has behind the walls. If some prep makes sense, I’ll point you to licensed pros I trust. Every dollar and cent matters.
Frequently asked questions
Can I buy a house with knob-and-tube wiring?
Yes. The question is whether an insurer will cover it as-is, so get a broker’s quote and an electrician’s bid before you remove contingencies.
Does homeowners insurance cover a cracked sewer line?
Wear and tear is generally excluded, and in the City of San Diego the lateral is the owner’s responsibility. Ask your broker what, if anything, applies.
Is earthquake coverage included?
No. Your insurer has to offer it for an added premium.
Sources
Consumer Financial Protection Bureau: Shop for homeowner’s insurance
California Department of Insurance: Residential Property Insurance Guide
California Department of Insurance: FAIR Plan growth slows below 2% (Aug. 3, 2026)
City of San Diego Development Services: Fire Hazard Severity Zone map update
California Earthquake Authority: How to qualify for a policy discount

Your agent
Nick Rotsart
Rather talk? Call or text.
(619) 853-2393
The Slice · a monthly letter
One email a month: what's happening, what's opening and maybe some real estate in between.